Template:Nhsc-v1-92 - Revision history

Reid Ginoza at 17:32, 24 March 2006

2006-03-24T17:32:21Z

Reid Ginoza at 17:30, 24 March 2006

2006-03-24T17:30:07Z

Jennifer Wada at 09:51, 8 March 2006

2006-03-08T09:51:18Z

New page

some socio-economic scale, but
does not answer the crucial
question: How true are their
l i v e s to native Hawaiian culture
and values?
It is not enough to look back a
century and reach certain conclusions,
not enouqh to probe the
past with modern s t a t i s t i c al
t o o l s , unless you also are able to
evaluate the Hawaiian experience
and ethics against a Hawaiian
concept. What may appear
undesirable in one culture can
have a logical explanation in
another. To do a t o t a l , meaningful
summation of Hawaiians, it
w i l l be necessary to measure them
against Hawaiian values (pp. 1-2).
4/ Schmitt, pp. 18-22
5/ Ibid., p. 16.
6/ Ibid., p. 68.
1J I b i d . , p. 114.
8/ Public Law 96-565, 96th
Congress (94 STAT. 3321), Title III,
Section 305, December 22, 1980.
9/ There was some confusion on
definitions used in the Commission's
Draft Report since these terms were
not always used consistently (see
comment by Herbert Jay (Nahaolelua)
Almeida). An attempt has been made to
correct that situation.
10/ Schmitt, p. 37.
11/ Adams, quoted in Schmitt,
p. 37.
12/ Trene B. Taeuber, "Hawaii,"
Population Index 28 (April 1962):98.
13/ Schmitt, p. 39.
14/ Andrew w. Lind, Hawaii 's
People, 3rd ed. (Honolulu: Ur.iversi.ty
of Hawaii Press,, 196";, p, 7.
15/ Ifrid., pp. L7-19.
16/ Neil Levy, "Native Kawai ian
Land Rights," The California Law_
Review, Volume * i (July 1975): S4'9.
17/ Ralph S. Kuykendall, The
Hawaiian Kingdom, Voiune 1, 1778-1834,
Foundation and Transformation
(Honolulu: University of Hawari
Press, 1968), pp. yn-89. [Hereinafter
cited as "Kuykendall, Volume I."!
18/ Ralpn S. Kuykendall and A.
Grove Day, Hawaii: A History, Frorr
Polynesian King i in to America onwealth
(New York: Prentice--ha*j
Inc. 1948;, p. 42.
19/ For example( see Taeuber, p.
98 (cited above;; Kuykendall and Day,
p. 43; Kuykendall, Volume I, pp.
89-90; Schmitt, p. 36; Adams, p. 7.
This paragraph was revised as the
result of a comment by Congressman
Daniel Akaka, who states: "The clam
that 'social disruption' was caused by
Kamehameha I becominq the prime aqent
for the sandalwood trade is made
without substance (p. 19-20), where
is the evidence for such a claim?
There is no citation to indicate the
source for this conclusion. Without
an identification of both the source
and the justification for its
conclusion, I find the statement
implausible since it suggests that the
Hawaiians are tc blare for their own
demise" (p. 3 ).
20, Taeuber, 108.
21/ Roman;'.o Adars, Inte_rraci a L
Marriage in Hawaii: A Study of the
Mutually Conditioned Processes of
Acculturation and Amalgamation,
reprinted fro;- 1 )37 ed. (New York:
AMS Press, 1969). pp. 3A-32.
{{p|92}}

@@ Line 43: / Line 43: @@
 Grove Day, <u>Hawaii: A History, From
 Polynesian Kingdom to American Commonwealth
-(New York: Prentice-Hall,
+</u>(New York: Prentice-Hall,
 Inc., 1948), p.42.

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-some socio-economic scale, but
+: some socio-economic scale, but does not answer the crucial question: How true are their lives to native Hawaiian culture and values?
 does not answer the crucial
-question: How true are their
+: It is not enough to look back a century and reach certain conclusions, not enouqh to probe the past with modern statistical tools, unless you also are able to evaluate the Hawaiian experience and ethics against a Hawaiian concept. What may appear undesirable in one culture can have a logical explanation in another. To do a total, meaningful summation of Hawaiians, it will be necessary to measure them against Hawaiian values (pp. 1-2).
-l i v e s to native Hawaiian culture
-and values?
+<u>4</u>/ Schmitt, pp. 18-22
 It is not enough to look back a
-century and reach certain conclusions,
+<u>5</u>/ <u>Ibid</u>., p. 16.
 not enouqh to probe the
-past with modern s t a t i s t i c al
+<u>6</u>/ <u>Ibid</u>., p. 68.
-t o o l s , unless you also are able to
-evaluate the Hawaiian experience
+<u>7</u>/ <u>Ibid</u>., p. 114.
 and ethics against a Hawaiian
-concept. What may appear
+<u>8</u>/ <u>Public Law 96-565</u>, 96th Congress (94 STAT. 3321), Title III, Section 305, December 22, 1980.
 undesirable in one culture can
-have a logical explanation in
+<u>9</u>/ There was some confusion on definitions used in the Commission's Draft Report since these terms were not always used consistently (see comment by Herbert Jay (Nahaolelua)
-another. To do a t o t a l , meaningful
+Almeida). An attempt has been made to correct that situation.
 summation of Hawaiians, it
-w i l l be necessary to measure them
+<u>10</u>/ Schmitt, p. 37.
 against Hawaiian values (pp. 1-2).
-/ Schmitt, pp. 18-22
+<u>11</u>/ Adams, quoted in Schmitt,
 p. 37.
 / Trene B. Taeuber, "Hawaii,"
-Population Index 28 (April 1962):98.
+<u>12</u>/ Trene B. Taeuber, "Hawaii,"
-/ Schmitt, p. 39.
+<u>Population</u> Index 28 (April 1962):98.
 / Andrew w. Lind, Hawaii 's
-People, 3rd ed. (Honolulu: Ur.iversi.ty
+<u>13</u>/ Schmitt, p. 39.
-of Hawaii Press,, 196";, p, 7.
-/ Ifrid., pp. L7-19.
+<u>14</u>/ Andrew w. Lind, <u>Hawaii's People</u>, 3rd ed. (Honolulu: University
-/ Neil Levy, "Native Kawai ian
+of Hawaii Press, 1967), p, 7.
-Land Rights," The California Law_
-Review, Volume * i (July 1975): S4'9.
+<u>15</u>/ <u>Ibid</u>., pp. 17-19.
 / Ralph S. Kuykendall, The
-Hawaiian Kingdom, Voiune 1, 1778-1834,
+<u>16</u>/ Neil Levy, "Native Hawaiian
-Foundation and Transformation
+Land Rights," <u>The California Law Review</u>, Volume 63 (July 1975): 849.
-(Honolulu: University of Hawari
-Press, 1968), pp. yn-89. [Hereinafter
+<u>17</u>/ Ralph S. Kuykendall, <u>The Hawaiian Kingdom, Volume 1, 1778-1854,
-cited as "Kuykendall, Volume I."!
+Foundation and Transformation </u>
-/ Ralpn S. Kuykendall and A.
+(Honolulu: University of Hawaii
-Grove Day, Hawaii: A History, Frorr
+Press, 1968), pp. 88-89. [Hereinafter
-Polynesian King i in to America onwealth
+cited as "Kuykendall, <u>Volume 1</u>."]
-(New York: Prentice--ha*j
-Inc. 1948;, p. 42.
+<u>18</u>/ Ralph S. Kuykendall and A.
-/ For example( see Taeuber, p.
+Grove Day, <u>Hawaii: A History, From
-(cited above;; Kuykendall and Day,
+Polynesian Kingdom to American Commonwealth
-p. 43; Kuykendall, Volume I, pp.
+(New York: Prentice-Hall,
--90; Schmitt, p. 36; Adams, p. 7.
+Inc., 1948), p.42.
 This paragraph was revised as the
 result of a comment by Congressman
-Daniel Akaka, who states: "The clam
+Daniel Akaka, who states: "The claim
 that 'social disruption' was caused by
-Kamehameha I becominq the prime aqent
+Kamehameha I becoming the prime aqent
 for the sandalwood trade is made
-without substance (p. 19-20), where
+without substance (p. 19-20). Where
 is the evidence for such a claim?
 There is no citation to indicate the
@@ Line 74: / Line 63: @@
 conclusion, I find the statement
 implausible since it suggests that the
-Hawaiians are tc blare for their own
+Hawaiians are to blame for their own
 demise" (p. 3 ).
-, Taeuber, 108.
-/ Roman;'.o Adars, Inte_rraci a L
+<u>20</u>/ Taeuber, 108.
 Marriage in Hawaii: A Study of the
 Mutually Conditioned Processes of
-Acculturation and Amalgamation,
+Acculturation and Amalgamation</u>,
-reprinted fro;- 1 )37 ed. (New York:
+reprinted from 1937 ed. (New York:
-AMS Press, 1969). pp. 3A-32.
+AMS Press, 1969). pp. 31-32.
 {{p|92}}