Difference between revisions of "Template:Nhsc-v1-262"
Reid Ginoza (talk | contribs) |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | LAND LAWS AND LAND RELATIONSHIPS | + | =LAND LAWS AND LAND RELATIONSHIPS= |
| − | NOTES | + | |
| − | 1/ An excellent description of | + | ==<u>NOTES</u>== |
| + | |||
| + | <u>1</u>/ An excellent description of | ||
ancient land tenure is contained in | ancient land tenure is contained in | ||
| − | Jon Chinen, The Great Mahele | + | Jon Chinen, <u>The Great Mahele</u> |
(Honolulu: University Press of | (Honolulu: University Press of | ||
Hawaii, 1958). Ono commenter, | Hawaii, 1958). Ono commenter, | ||
| Line 13: | Line 15: | ||
appears in full in the Appendix of | appears in full in the Appendix of | ||
this report. | this report. | ||
| − | 2/ Some commenters suggested that | + | |
| + | <u>2</u>/ Some commenters suggested that | ||
a comparison to European feudal | a comparison to European feudal | ||
systems leads to oversimplification. | systems leads to oversimplification. | ||
| Line 19: | Line 22: | ||
literature on Hawaiian tenure, | literature on Hawaiian tenure, | ||
however. (See also above, p. 148.) | however. (See also above, p. 148.) | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | 4/ Change suggested by comments | + | <u>3</u>/ Chinen, <u>The Great Mahele</u>, p. 3. |
| + | |||
| + | <u>4</u>/ Change suggested by comments | ||
received from the Office of Hawaiian | received from the Office of Hawaiian | ||
Affairs (OHA). | Affairs (OHA). | ||
| − | 5/ This paragraph is based on Jon | + | |
| − | Chinen, The Great Mahele, and on Neil | + | <u>5</u>/ This paragraph is based on Jon |
| + | Chinen, <u>The Great Mahele</u>, and on Neil | ||
M. Levy, "Native Hawaiian Land | M. Levy, "Native Hawaiian Land | ||
| − | Rights," 63 Cal. Law Review 848 | + | Rights," 63 <u>Cal. Law Review</u> 848 |
(1975), pp. 848-9, and Melody K. | (1975), pp. 848-9, and Melody K. | ||
| − | MacKenzie, Sovereignty and Land: | + | MacKenzie, <u>Sovereignty and Land: |
| − | Honoring the Hawaiian Native Claim | + | Honoring the Hawaiian Native Claim</u> |
(OHA), pp. 1-2. See also, for | (OHA), pp. 1-2. See also, for | ||
general background, Ralph Kuykendall, | general background, Ralph Kuykendall, | ||
| − | The Hawaiian Kingdom, Vol. I, | + | <u>The Hawaiian Kingdom, Vol. I, |
| − | 1778-1854, "Chapter IV: The Land | + | 1778-1854</u>, "Chapter IV: The Land |
Revolution." One commenter submitted | Revolution." One commenter submitted | ||
another helpful article: Thomas | another helpful article: Thomas | ||
Marshall Spaulding, "The Crown Lands | Marshall Spaulding, "The Crown Lands | ||
of Hawaii" (Univ. of Hawaii, Oct. 10, | of Hawaii" (Univ. of Hawaii, Oct. 10, | ||
| − | 1923) . | + | 1923). |
| − | 6/ Ibid. | + | |
| − | 7/ MacKenzie, Sovereignty and | + | <u>6</u>/ <u>Ibid</u> . |
| + | |||
| + | <u>7</u>/ MacKenzie, <u>Sovereignty and | ||
Land: Honoring the Hawaiian Native | Land: Honoring the Hawaiian Native | ||
| − | Claim, p. 3. | + | Claim</u>, p. 3. |
| − | 9/ Hawaii State Dept. of | + | |
| − | and Finance, Land and Water Resource | + | <u>9</u>/ Hawaii State Dept. of Budget8 |
| − | Management in Hawaii (Honolulu: | + | and Finance, <u>Land and Water Resource |
| + | Management in Hawaii</u> (Honolulu: | ||
Hawaii Institute for Management and | Hawaii Institute for Management and | ||
Analysis in Government, 1978), p. 148. | Analysis in Government, 1978), p. 148. | ||
| − | 9/ Levy, p. 879; MacKenzie, p. 3. | + | |
| − | 10/ David Malo, Hawaiian | + | <u>9</u>/ Levy, p. 879; MacKenzie, p. 3. |
| − | Antiquities (Moolelo Hawaii) | + | |
| + | <u>10</u>/ David Malo, <u>Hawaiian | ||
| + | Antiquities</u> <u>(Moolelo Hawaii)</u> | ||
(Honolulu: Bishop Museum Press, | (Honolulu: Bishop Museum Press, | ||
1951), p. 53; quoted in MacKenzie, | 1951), p. 53; quoted in MacKenzie, | ||
p. 3." | p. 3." | ||
| − | 11/ MacKenzie, p. 3. | + | |
| − | 12/ Levy, p. 850. | + | <u>11</u>/ MacKenzie, p. 3. |
| − | 13/ MacKenzie, pp. 4-5. | + | |
| − | 14/ Levy, p. 850; MacKenzie, p. | + | <u>12</u>/ Levy, p. 850. |
| + | |||
| + | <u>13</u>/ MacKenzie, pp. 4-5. | ||
| + | |||
| + | <u>14</u>/ Levy, p. 850; MacKenzie, p. | ||
5. | 5. | ||
| − | 15/ Ibid. | + | |
| − | + | <u>15</u>/ <u>Ibid</u> . | |
| − | 17/ As quoted in Kuykendall, The | + | |
| − | Hawaiian Kingdom, 1778-1854, p. 271. | + | <u>16</u>/ <u>Ibid</u> . |
| − | 18/ See generally, Levy, pp. | + | |
| + | <u>17</u>/ As quoted in Kuykendall, <u>The | ||
| + | Hawaiian Kingdom, 1778-1854</u>, p. 271. | ||
| + | |||
| + | <u>18</u>/ See generally, Levy, pp. | ||
851-2; MacKenzie, pp. 5-7. | 851-2; MacKenzie, pp. 5-7. | ||
| − | 19/ MacKenzie, p. 7. | + | |
| − | 20/ Levy, pp. 852-853, MacKenzie, | + | <u>19</u>/ MacKenzie, p. 7. |
| − | p . 7. | + | |
| − | 262 | + | <u>20</u>/ Levy, pp. 852-853, MacKenzie, |
| + | p. 7. | ||
| + | {{p|262}} | ||
Revision as of 21:03, 23 April 2006
LAND LAWS AND LAND RELATIONSHIPS
NOTES
1/ An excellent description of ancient land tenure is contained in Jon Chinen, The Great Mahele (Honolulu: University Press of Hawaii, 1958). Ono commenter, Haunani-Kay Trask, thought that the presentation in this section was so biased and inaccurate that she re-wrote it. The Commission does not adopt her alternate language, which appears in full in the Appendix of this report.
2/ Some commenters suggested that a comparison to European feudal systems leads to oversimplification. The comparison is used throughout the literature on Hawaiian tenure, however. (See also above, p. 148.)
3/ Chinen, The Great Mahele, p. 3.
4/ Change suggested by comments received from the Office of Hawaiian Affairs (OHA).
5/ This paragraph is based on Jon Chinen, The Great Mahele, and on Neil M. Levy, "Native Hawaiian Land Rights," 63 Cal. Law Review 848 (1975), pp. 848-9, and Melody K. MacKenzie, Sovereignty and Land: Honoring the Hawaiian Native Claim (OHA), pp. 1-2. See also, for general background, Ralph Kuykendall, The Hawaiian Kingdom, Vol. I, 1778-1854, "Chapter IV: The Land Revolution." One commenter submitted another helpful article: Thomas Marshall Spaulding, "The Crown Lands of Hawaii" (Univ. of Hawaii, Oct. 10, 1923).
6/ Ibid .
7/ MacKenzie, Sovereignty and Land: Honoring the Hawaiian Native Claim, p. 3.
9/ Hawaii State Dept. of Budget8 and Finance, Land and Water Resource Management in Hawaii (Honolulu: Hawaii Institute for Management and Analysis in Government, 1978), p. 148.
9/ Levy, p. 879; MacKenzie, p. 3.
10/ David Malo, Hawaiian Antiquities (Moolelo Hawaii) (Honolulu: Bishop Museum Press, 1951), p. 53; quoted in MacKenzie, p. 3."
11/ MacKenzie, p. 3.
12/ Levy, p. 850.
13/ MacKenzie, pp. 4-5.
14/ Levy, p. 850; MacKenzie, p. 5.
15/ Ibid .
16/ Ibid .
17/ As quoted in Kuykendall, The Hawaiian Kingdom, 1778-1854, p. 271.
18/ See generally, Levy, pp. 851-2; MacKenzie, pp. 5-7.
19/ MacKenzie, p. 7.
20/ Levy, pp. 852-853, MacKenzie, p. 7.
|
